He is bonkers, but not because of his claim that there are aliens, but because he made a species up.

Just hope he doesn't find any secret/hidden doors.

Not sure about that. He is very skinny and all bones.

He has a little blood left, but I do not have information on his adrenalin stats.

Good for them then.

That sounds like quite a claim.  Though it is obviously quite improbable.  Although, I put some of the things you mentioned into question:

What exactly is so funny about aliens being non-hostile?  How do you know this man has little blood left?  Why does it take aliens to know his language and teach him their language?  Now as for the last question I asked is more the one I'm interested in.  It brings me to two questions:

Assuming what you say is true, and these aliens knew Serbian, couldn't it still be necessary to learn their language?  For example, what if they had important things to tell him that they wanted to make sure no one else could understand if overheard?

As for my second question, how are you so sure that he can't learn their language without someone to translate or for them to know Serbian?  Isn't it possible that there are other ways of learning, such as by means of simply figuring it out, similar to how we all learn our first language?  Though I know that is arguable, as others would say how our brain changes throughout time and we lose certain abilities that we had as a child that would otherwise enable us to learn these things, but none of this is proven fact either, thereby still plausible.

Now don't get me wrong, it's not that I think this guy is telling the truth and actually believe what he was saying, as I said above, this is very improbable, but all I'm ultimately trying to say is can you really dismiss these things with absolute certainty as well?  There are plenty of people who believe in aliens, either out of interest, plausibility, delusions, being "abducted," talking to them, whatever the case might be.  Quite a number of these people have also, at least claimed they didn't believe in aliens before hand, and now do.  Either way, I don't feel it should be dismissed with such certainty that you assume it's definitely wrong.

I myself do believe in aliens, however I don't believe in the abductions, talking to them or whatever.  I more so just simply think they exist.  The...multiverse is arguably infinite, I find it hard to believe we are the only planet in it that has "life."  Though that can also depend on how you define what life is, which is a completely different argument.

(Sorry for the long post by the way)

Figuring it out in the sense that you are taking it would be impossible (or at least very, very improbable), because children "figure out"   their mother tongue by examples e.g. they learn that a spoon is a spoon when they are shown a spoon while the word "spoon" is told to them. It can be thought of as a so called firm ofconditional learning. The same kind of technique cannot be applied here, because of the distance.

Okay, so assuming you are right about that, why can it not be done, what are the specific reasons as to why this same technique can not be applied?  From what you said, he already saw their spaceships, how do you know he was not physically communicating with them as well?  On top of that, there are still other ways (going a little more extreme here), I'm sure you've heard of mental telepathy?  Arguably, that is what he could have been doing the whole time, so why can't they teach him first with such things as pictures and images?

Also, you still proved my point when you said, "Figuring it out in the sense that you are taking it would be impossible (or at least very, very improbable),..." because I never once said I believe this guy, only arguing that it is possible, and very, very improbable is still possible, unless you DO literally mean impossible.

By the way, if you feel I am taking this argument too far, then you can just simply tell me to stop.  I saw this topic and got interested so decided to play devil's advocate, mostly because regardless of how slim of a possibility it is, I see the possibility in all of it, and all-in-all felt like proving it if one didn't agree.  My intention here is not to .... well be an ***hole, so if you feel that's what I'm doing then I apologize and will immediately back off.

Well it is quite interesting you brought this up.  However, I feel it is mostly unwise to even proceed answering that.  You are beginning to change the subject and turn this more into a philosophical discussion, which was never my intention.  As I said here...

I see the possibility in all of it, and all-in-all felt like proving it if one didn't agree.

I feel like mostly I already made my case and that was my intention.  If I proceed to answer that, I don't feel it would be very appropriate, sorry...

See I was thinking this: if it leads to something more controversial, regardless HOW you say or try to put it, it can be insulting to the other person.  Like your intention was not to insult them in the first place, yet they get insulted by what you say, that is why I was thinking it wasn't a good idea to continue.  But you're saying it is okay anonimnystefy?

What do you think might be insulting and to who? And why?

How many folks in the world believe in angels, demons, God, etc.  Are they not "aliens" when
compared to the human race?  And is it possible that they live in 4 or more dimensions so that
they can be invisible to us when they want to be?  So there are perhaps billions of people that
"believe in aliens."  Depends on one's definition of "alien."

I was worried about answering that, because I believe that could lead into a controversial matter, and I do NOT want to insult anyone even if that is not my intention.  From my personal experience, I try to hold back from getting involved with those matters, unless I know the person, because I do not want to it to be saying stuff that can possible offend the other person, just because its based off of my own beliefs...

I was just expressing my opinion. There is absolutely no reason someone should be offended.

You'd be surprised.  The issue is that you never know what the person is thinking, nor what he believes and values.  What you say can be perceived many different ways, and typically when saying something, you only see it how you meant it.  The other person can however misunderstand anything you said (or at least how you meant it), which can thereby lead to that person being offended.

Sorry... especially when I was younger, people misunderstanding what I was saying which often leading to unintentional offense happened quite a lot.  Eventually, I learned to be very careful, arguably too careful, yet even still, I am always worrying that what I say can offend someone and am always trying to be very careful about it.  This kind of thing especially happens all the time when talking about controversial matters, which is why I tend to avoid them, and is the exact reason I thought it was not wise to answer that question in the first place.

Last edited by Calligar (2012-10-11 16:55:37)

There would still be no way of him figuring out their language in a week. And his genious would have been recognized by now...